Comparison of Carob Molasses and Grape Molasses
Carob molasses and grape molasses are two traditional products in Turkey that have a wide range of uses, from breakfast tables to desserts. Both are obtained by condensing fruit-derived sugars; however, they differ from each other in terms of raw materials, production steps, taste profiles and some quality indicators.
In this article, we compare the two molasses with the data reported in scientific studies; we discuss in a measured language where they are similar and different in terms of sugar profile, HMF, mineral content, antioxidant capacity, taste and culinary use. The aim is not to declare one "better", but to help make an informed choice by correctly defining their differences.
Two Molasses, Two Different Raw Materials
Molasses is the common name for traditional products obtained by condensing fruit must in Turkish cuisine. Molasses can be made from different fruits such as grapes, mulberries, carob, apples, pears, pomegranates and junipers. However, since the structure of each fruit is different, the path of these products with the same name from raw material to final product also differs.
Grape molasses is produced by boiling the must obtained from fresh grapes and thickening it. The raw material is a juicy fruit; that is, the must comes directly from the juice of the fruit itself. In carob molasses, the starting point is the carob fruit, which has been left to dry and has very little juice. In order to take the sugars and other water-soluble components in the dried fruit into the liquid phase, the fruit is first broken and then extraction is applied with water; the resulting must is filtered and condensed. Yavuz Küçük and Duraklı Velioğlu (2022) also define carob molasses as a traditional Turkish food made by clarifying and thickening fruit must.
This fundamental difference is reflected in many features of the two molasses, from taste to consistency, from color to some quality indicators. The production stages of carob molasses in detail What is Carob Molasses and How is it Made? Since we explained it in our article, we will only touch on the points needed for comparison here.
Major Differences in the Manufacturing Process
A common traditional practice in grape molasses production is the use of "molasses soil". In the study conducted by Kurnaz et al. (2016) in the Zile district of Tokat, it is stated that this soil used in the production of grape molasses contains calcium oxide (CaO) and is added to remove the acidity in the must. In the same study, the average CaO ratio in the soil samples examined was reported as 30.52 percent. This practice is a traditional step towards balancing and clarifying the natural acidity of the grape must.
In carob molasses, the process proceeds with a different logic as it starts with extraction from dried fruit. Critical stages here; cleaning the fruit, breaking it to the appropriate size, extracting it by soaking it with water or heating, filtering and condensing the must.
| Feature | Carob molasses | Grape molasses |
|---|---|---|
| Raw Material | Dried carob fruit | Fresh grapes |
| Obtaining the must | Extraction from crushed fruit with water | The sap obtained by squeezing the fruit |
| Traditional pre-treatment | Cleaning, crushing, holding/heating | Deacidification and clarification with molasses soil |
| Condensation | Boiling in an open boiler or vacuum evaporation | Boiling in an open boiler or vacuum evaporation |
| Availability of raw materials | It can be stored throughout the year as dried fruit | Attached to fresh fruit, concentrates on the harvest period |
The difference in the last line is important in practice: Since carob can be stored as a dried fruit under suitable conditions, molasses production can be spread throughout the year. Grape molasses, on the other hand, is a production that traditionally intensifies during the vintage period.
Sugar Profile: Closer Than Expected
Both molasses are a dense source of sugar, and this is due to the nature of the product. The study by Dilek et al. (2025), which examined eight different types of molasses procured from local producers in Turkey, is one of the current sources that offers the opportunity to compare the two products with the same method. In this study, the total sugar content was measured as 44.79 g/100 g in carob molasses and 43.84 g/100 g in grape molasses. In both examples, fructose was the dominant sugar (carob 17.25 g/100 g; grapes 17.62 g/100 g). Glucose values were also close to each other (carob 10.67 g/100 g; grapes 11.00 g/100 g).
These results show that the two molasses are not far from each other in terms of sugar content. However, it is important to note that these values are obtained from a limited number of local samples for each type of molasses and may vary depending on the raw material, production method, and degree of condensation. For example, in the same study, total soluble dry matter was reported as 78.57 percent in carob molasses and 79.23 percent in grape molasses.
In the Cyprus study examining carob syrups (Papaefstathiou et al., 2018), the sugar content in different carob syrups was found to be between approximately 56 percent and 62 percent. This difference between different studies reflects the diversity in the production conditions of the products and the difference in the analysis methods used.
- Both molasses are obtained by condensing natural fruit sugars.
- In the comparison made with the same method, the total sugar amounts are close to each other.
- Portion control is important with both products due to their high sugar content.
HMF and Heat Treatment Effect
Hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF) is a compound that can be formed by heat treatment or long-term storage of sugar-containing foods. It is considered one of the important quality indicators that give an idea about the intensity of heat treatment and freshness in molasses.
In the study by Dilek et al. (2025), HMF was measured as 3.89 mg/kg in carob molasses and 134.53 mg/kg in grape molasses. In the same study, the authors state that the HMF limit in the legislation for grape molasses is 75 mg/kg and that the carob molasses examined remained below this value. The rules regarding grape molasses are regulated by the Turkish Food Codex Communiqué on Grape Molasses (Communiqué No: 2017/8) published in the Official Gazette dated June 30, 2017.
It would not be correct to generalize this comparison as "HMF is always low in carob molasses". HMF level; It depends on boiling time, temperature, open boiler or vacuum use and storage conditions. As a matter of fact, Özcan et al. (2015), who examined grape molasses produced by the traditional method in the Tashkent district of Konya, found HMF values between 3.312 and 6.336 mg/kg in these samples. Yavuz Küçük and Duraklı Velioğlu (2022) also reported that HMF in carob molasses collected from the market varies in a wide range between 0.79 and 50.25 mg/kg. In other words, production and storage conditions are more decisive than the type of product.
A study on apple molasses (Kuşçu and Bulantekin, 2016) showed that HMF was formed in molasses produced in an open boiler, while HMF was not detected in molasses produced by vacuum. Although this finding belongs to a different fruit, it is a guide to understand the effect of the condensation method on HMF.
Mineral Content: Potassium Stands Out
Molasses carries some of the minerals found in the fruit in concentrated form. For this reason, both carob and grape molasses contain minerals such as potassium, calcium and magnesium.
In the study of Papaefstathiou et al. (2018), potassium was measured between 628 and 1049 mg/100 g in carob syrups examined; the authors stated that carob syrup has a "high potassium content" compared to European Union reference intake values. On the grape molasses side, Özcan et al. (2015) reported that high levels of potassium, magnesium, sodium, phosphorus and calcium were found in all the samples they examined.
In the study of Aliyazıcıoğlu et al. (2009), who compared different types of molasses from Turkey, it was reported that selenium and other minerals were slightly higher in grape molasses than in other samples. In the same study, it was also emphasized that the general chemical compositions of the samples were similar to each other.
These data show that both molasses are products that can be evaluated in terms of minerals; however, it shows that the answer to the question "which one has more" may vary depending on the sample, the soil where the raw material is grown and the production method. The possible effect of the molasses soil used in grape molasses on the mineral content is also an issue that needs to be investigated.
Antioxidant Capacity and Phenolic Compounds
Carob is a fruit rich in phenolic compounds and this feature is partially reflected in molasses. In the study of Aliyazıcıoğlu et al. (2009), carob molasses showed the highest DPPH radical removal activity among the samples examined. Total phenolic matter was found in the range of 138-243 mg gallic acid equivalent/100 g in the samples; the highest value was measured in apricot molasses.
Such laboratory measurements give a comparative idea of the antioxidant capacity of the products. However, it should be noted that the antioxidant activity measured in the tube does not directly mean that it will have the same effect in the body. When choosing molasses, it is more accurate to consider these data not as "health claims", but as information that helps to understand the difference in composition of the products.
Taste, Color, and Sensory Differences
The most obvious difference between the two molasses is the taste itself. Grape molasses is fruity, slightly tart and has a familiar sweetness; its color can vary from light brown to dark red, depending on the grape used. Carob molasses, on the other hand, has a darker aroma reminiscent of cocoa and caramel, with slightly astringent notes.
An example of how this difference is reflected in consumer preferences is the yogurt study of Karaca et al. (2012). In the study, grape, mulberry and carob molasses were added to the set yogurt in different proportions; in the sensory evaluation, grape molasses yoghurts received the highest score, followed by mulberry and carob molasses samples. As the molasses content increased, the mineral content of yoghurts also increased significantly. This result suggests that the characteristic and more dominant aroma of carob molasses should be dosed more carefully in some products.
- Carob molasses: dark color, notes of cocoa and caramel, slightly astringent taste
- Grape molasses: fruity aroma, more familiar sweetness, color variable depending on the grape
- The consistency depends on the degree of condensation and temperature in both products
Which One Is Used Where In The Kitchen?
Both molasses can be mixed with tahini and consumed for breakfast, added to yogurt, oats or desserts. However, one stands out in some uses because their taste profiles are different.
| Usage | Carob molasses | Grape molasses |
|---|---|---|
| Tahini molasses | It gives a cocoa-like and intense flavor | Gives a more fruity and classic taste |
| Cocoa desserts and cakes | Compatible with chocolatey flavor | Available, the aroma is more fruity |
| Salad dressings and marinades | Adds a small amount of depth | It is frequently preferred due to its sour note |
| Yoghurt and dairy products | Pronounced aroma, the dose needs to be carefully adjusted | It was more appreciated in sensory work |
It is usually possible to use one instead of the other in the recipe; however, since the aroma of carob molasses is more dominant, it is a good method to try it with a slightly smaller amount at the beginning and increase it to taste.
What to Consider When Buying?
Regardless of the type of molasses, it is necessary to pay attention to the information on the label to distinguish a quality product. According to Turkish food legislation, it is forbidden to add glucose syrup, high fructose corn syrup or other sugar to molasses (Yaman and Duraklı Velioğlu, 2019). Despite this, such imitation practices are a problem encountered from time to time. Yaman and Duraklı Velioğlu (2019) developed a method to determine whether glucose syrup is added to grape, carob and mulberry molasses by FTIR spectroscopy and chemometric methods and tested it with real adulterated samples from the market.
- Check that only the respective fruit (and water if necessary) is included in the ingredient list.
- Make sure the manufacturer's name, address, and batch information are included on the label.
- Observe the storage conditions on the packaging; heat and long storage can increase the formation of HMF.
- Remember that crystallization alone is not an indicator of fakeness, but can be caused by the sugar composition.
Frequently Asked Questions
Carob molasses or grape molasses with less sugar? In a comparison made with the same method, the total sugar amounts were found to be very close to each other (carob 44.79 g/100 g; grapes 43.84 g/100 g; Dilek et al., 2025). Both are dense sources of sugar.
Which has lower HMF? In a single study, HMF was measured much lower in carob molasses; however, HMF mainly depends on production and storage conditions. Low values have also been reported in some grape molasses produced by the traditional method.
Which one should be used in tahini molasses? This depends entirely on taste preference. Carob molasses gives a cocoa-like result, grape molasses gives a fruitier result.
Can diabetics consume molasses? Both molasses contain high levels of sugar. People who need blood sugar control should plan their molasses consumption with their doctor or dietitian.
Carob Raw Material with Carob Türkiye
The quality of carob molasses is highly dependent on the quality of the starting raw material. At Carob Türkiye, we supply carob fruit, crumbs, flour/powder, seeds, and extracts. Businesses looking for raw materials for molasses or syrup production Carob Fruit and Carob Kibble (Granular) You can review our pages; for wholesale and export requests Contact Now You can reach us on our page.
For more information about carob molasses What is Carob Molasses and How is it Made? and What is Carob Extract? You can read our articles.
This content is for informational purposes only; it is not a substitute for medical advice.
Domestic resources
Yavuz Küçük, A., Duraklı Velioğlu, S., "Determination of Some Chemical Properties of the Product Offered for Sale Under the Name of 'Carob Extract' and Comparison with Carob Molasses", Gıda, 47(5), 889–903, 2022. doi.
org/ 10. 15237/ food. GD22033 Kurnaz, A., Turhan, Ş., Gezelge, M., Hançerlioğulları, A., Çetiner, M. A., "Elemental Composition of Soils Mixed with the Grape Molasses", Turkish Journal of Agriculture – Food Science and Technology, 4(9), 748–751, 2016. doi.
org/ 10. 24925/ turjaf. v4i9. 748- 751. 824 Official Gazette of the Republic of Turkey, 30 June 2017 issue: "Turkish Food Codex Communiqué on Grape Molasses (No: 2017/8)", 2017. official newspaper.
gov. en/ The ancients/ 2017/ 06/ 20170630. htm Aliyazıcıoğlu, R., Kolaylı, S., Kara, M., Yıldız, O., Sarıkaya, A. O., Cengiz, S., Er, F., "Determination of Chemical, Physical and Biological Characteristics of Some Pekmez (Molasses) From Turkey", Asian Journal of Chemistry, 21(3), 2215–2223, 2009. I'm hungry.
Selcuk. edu. en/ items/ 1003AAD7- 3ca8- 46fc- 8990- 4f... Foreign sources
Dilek, N. M., Babaoğlu, A. S., Ünal, K., Turan, M., Pırlak, L., Karakaya, M., "Nutritional Profile and Functional Characteristics of Various Types of Traditionally Produced PEKMEZ—Part I", Food Science & Nutrition, 13(7), e70662, 2025. doi.
org/ 10. 1002/ FSN3. 70662 Papaefstathiou, E., Agapiou, A., Giannopoulos, S., Kokkinofta, R., "Nutritional characterization of carobs and traditional carob products", Food Science & Nutrition, 6(8), 2151–2161, 2018. doi.
org/ 10. 1002/ FSN3. 776 Özcan, M. M., Alpar, Ş., Al Juhaimi, F., "The effect of boiling on qualitative properties of grape juice produced by the traditional method", Journal of Food Science and Technology, 52(9), 5546–5556, 2015. doi.
org/ 10. 1007/ S13197- 014- 1628- 8 Yaman, N., Duraklı Velioğlu, S., "Use of Attenuated Total Reflectance-Fourier Transform Infrared (ATR-FTIR) Spectroscopy in Combination with Multivariate Methods for the Rapid Determination of the Adulteration of Grape, Carob and Mulberry Molasses", Foods, 8(7), 231, 2019. doi.
org/ 10. 3390/ foods8070231 Karaca, O. B., Saydam, İ. B., Güven, M., "Physicochemical, mineral and sensory properties of set-type yoghurts produced by addition of grape, mulberry and carob molasses (Pekmez) at different ratios", International Journal of Dairy Technology, 65(1), 111–117, 2012. doi.
org/ 10. 1111/ j. 1471- 0307. 2011. 00731. x Kuşçu, A., Bulantekin, Ö., "The effects of production methods and storage on the chemical constituents of apple molasses", Journal of Food Science and Technology, 53(7), 3083–3092, 2016. doi.
Scientific Resourcesorg/ 10. 1007/ S13197- 016- 2281- 1
